- 1960-69
- Gordon Banks, 1959-67, LG: 293 *
- George Heyes, 1960-66, LG: 27
- Peter Shilton, 1966-74, LG: 286 *
- Colin Mackleworth, 1967-71, LG: 6
- 1970-79
- Carl Jayes, 1971-78, LG: 5
- Mark Wallington, 1971-85, LG: 412
- Sean Rafter, 1977-79, LG: 0
- Steve Humphries, 1978-81, LG: 0
- 1980-89
- Ian Andrews, 1982-88, LG: 126
- Jeremey Roberts, 1984-86, LG: 3
- Mark Grew, 1983-84, LG: 5
- Carl Muggleton, 1986-94, LG: 46
- Paul Cooper, 1987-1989, LG: 56
- Martin Hodge, 1988-91, LG: 75
- 1990-99
- Russell Hoult, 1991-95, LG: 10
- Kevin Poole, 1991-97, LG: 163
- Gavin Ward, 1993-95, LG: 38
- Zeilko Kalac, 1995-96, LG: 2
- Kasey Keller, 1996-99, LG: 99 *
- Pegguy Arphexad, 1997-00, LG: 21
- Tim Flowers, 1999-03, LG: 56
- Alan Fettis, 1999, LG: 0
- 2000-09
- Ian Walker, 2001-05, LG: 140 *
- Jimmy Nielsen,
- Simon Royce, 2000-03, LG: 19
- Danny Coyne, 2003-04, LG: 4
- Paul Henderson, 2005-09, LG: 63
- Conrad Logan, 2005-15, LG:
- David Martyn, 2008-09, LG: 25
- Ben Alnwick, 2008, LG: 8
- Mark Bunn, 2009, LG: 3
- Tony Warner, 2009, LG: 4
- Chris Weale, 2009-12, LG: 75
- 2010-19
- Kasper Schmeichel, 2011-2022, LG:
- Mark Schwarzer,
- Ron-Robert Zieler,
- Ben Hamer,
- Daniel Iversen,
- Danny Ward,
- Jakub Stolarczyk,
- 2020 ->
- Mads Hermansen
